A family on the run. Creatures that hunt by sound. A promising survival story that never quite finds its own voice.
🎬 The Silence Review: A Promising Idea, an Uneven Movie
Imagine a world where even the smallest sound can get you killed. That is the nightmare at the heart of The Silence, a creature feature with an intriguing setup and a disappointingly ordinary execution.
Stanley Tucci gives the film a steady emotional center, and several survival scenes deliver real tension. However, weak CGI, inconsistent creature rules, and a rushed human threat keep it from becoming something special. TomsVerdict: 6/10.
The Silence (2019): Film Information
- Film
- The Silence
- Year
- 2019
- Language
- English
- Director
- John R. Leonetti
- Genre
- Horror, Sci-Fi
- Style
- Post-apocalyptic creature feature; survival thriller
- Runtime
- 90 minutes
- Age Rating
- PG-13 (US)
- Based On
- The Silence, Tim Lebbon’s 2015 novel
- Netflix Release
- April 10, 2019
The Silence Ratings
External scores can change. TomsVerdict’s score is an independent editorial opinion. View Rotten Tomatoes ratings.
Story Overview: A World Forced Into Silence
A research team exploring a cave in Pennsylvania uncovers an unknown species that has remained isolated underground. The creatures are blind, can fly, and feed on flesh. Their hearing is so sharp that sound alone is enough to guide them toward their prey.
Once the Vesps escape, the threat spreads rapidly. Cities become dangerous, and ordinary life starts to fall apart. The familiar sounds of traffic, conversation, and movement become things people can no longer afford to make.
At the center of the story is the Andrews family. Sixteen-year-old Ally lost her hearing at 13 after an accident. As a result, her parents and other family members already communicate with her through sign language. This knowledge becomes useful when staying quiet is essential.
Hugh and Kelly take their family out of the city, hoping to find a safer place. However, every stage of the journey presents another problem. They must navigate the creatures, limited resources, and people whose behavior becomes more threatening as civilization breaks down.
A religious group called The Hushed eventually adds another danger. Its members want Ally, and their interest turns an already difficult struggle for survival into something more disturbing.
The Silence: Official Netflix Trailer
Trailer source: Netflix’s official YouTube upload.
Behind the Story: More Than an A Quiet Place Copy
Around 2018 and 2019, films such as A Quiet Place and Bird Box helped make sensory horror a major talking point. One story turned sound into a deadly risk, while the other made sight dangerous. The Silence arrived in the middle of that conversation, so comparisons were almost inevitable.
However, calling it a direct copy overlooks an important detail. Tim Lebbon’s novel was published in 2015, before A Quiet Place reached cinemas. The source material therefore predates the movie people most often compare it with. That does not excuse the adaptation’s weaknesses, but it does make the accusation of copying too simplistic.
Director John R. Leonetti also has a notable background behind the camera. He worked as a cinematographer on The Mask and The Conjuring. His directing credits include Annabelle and Wish Upon. Here, though, an interesting premise never develops into the sustained dread it could have delivered.
The adaptation feels more interested in immediate survival incidents than in the wider environmental and social questions its premise raises. A world suddenly forced into silence should offer plenty of room for unsettling ideas. Instead, the film usually moves on to the next obstacle before those ideas can settle.
Ally’s casting and deaf representation
The film also faced criticism over casting a hearing actress, Kiernan Shipka, as Ally and over its depiction of American Sign Language. This is worth separating from the character’s situation: Ally is deaf, not unable to speak. Her family’s use of signing is an established part of their lives, rather than a skill they suddenly learn after the outbreak.
The Andrews Family: The Film’s Human Center
Stanley Tucci is the strongest reason to stay invested. His Hugh is not an action hero with all the answers. He is a father trying to make decisions quickly while keeping fear from overwhelming the people who depend on him. That calm, determined presence helps ground an otherwise uneven story.
Kiernan Shipka’s Ally gives the premise its central perspective. Her experience matters to the family’s survival, but the script does not always give her enough room to become more than the person around whom its main idea is built. Miranda Otto brings a recognizable sense of concern to Kelly, although she also has limited material to work with.
The family is easy enough to follow and care about. Even so, I wanted more quiet moments that revealed who they were before the crisis. A little more emotional detail would have made the danger feel more personal.

What Worked Well
Stanley Tucci carries the weaker material
Even when the screenplay feels thin, Tucci keeps Hugh believable. I liked the way he balances responsibility with fear. He rarely needs a big speech to make the father’s concern clear, and that restraint suits a film built around the need for silence.
The strongest scenes turn sound into a weapon
Some of the later sequences become genuinely tense when the Vesps threaten the family’s shelter. The film works best when its characters have to think about where a sound will travel and what it might attract. Using noise against the creatures is more engaging than simply watching people run away from them.
The human threat introduces a darker idea
The arrival of The Hushed adds something different to the survival plot. When normal life collapses, fear can give extreme beliefs a powerful hold over people. That possibility is disturbing, and it briefly opens the door to a more interesting kind of horror.
A short, accessible creature feature
The 90-minute runtime is another advantage. The story does not spend too long delaying its central conflict. As a result, it is easy to watch in one sitting, particularly if you want a straightforward survival thriller rather than a demanding horror film.
Where It Falls Short
The comparison it cannot escape
A Quiet Place is a difficult film to follow. Although the two stories are not identical, both ask audiences to fear the consequences of making noise. Unfortunately, The Silence does not come close to the same balance of sound design, emotional stakes, and tension.
That comparison is not the only reason the movie struggles. Even on its own terms, the suspense rises and falls too unevenly. Several scenes introduce an urgent problem without developing it into a sequence that feels truly unpredictable.
CGI weakens the creatures
The Vesps sometimes look threatening, especially when they are glimpsed in groups. In other shots, however, they appear artificial or almost cartoonish. Once the illusion breaks, it becomes harder to feel the fear the scene is trying to create.
Too much potential, too little development
The Hushed are the clearest example of a promising idea that arrives too late and ends too quickly. The film raises questions about belief, control, and exploitation, then gives them little time to develop. Consequently, this part of the story feels more like an extra obstacle than a fully realized threat.
The Vesps: An Effective Concept With Unclear Rules
Blind creatures that locate prey through sound are a strong foundation for suspense. A dropped object, a sudden cry, or a badly timed movement can become a life-or-death mistake. The audience should understand that danger well enough to anticipate it before the characters do.
Here, the rules feel inconsistent. Sometimes a small noise attracts an immediate response. At other times, louder activity seems to pass without the same consequences. This makes it feel as though the creatures’ hearing changes to suit the scene.
For me, that is a bigger problem than the effects alone. Horror becomes more convincing when its threats have clear limits. Without that consistency, the tension depends too much on when the screenplay decides an attack should happen.
The Hushed: A Missed Opportunity
The Hushed turn silence into a form of religious devotion. Their self-imposed muteness and interest in Ally suggest a group that uses the disaster to justify its own disturbing agenda. Netflix’s synopsis describes them as seeking to exploit her heightened senses.
I found the idea more interesting than its execution. The creatures pose an immediate physical danger, while the cult introduces deliberate human cruelty. That contrast could have given the final stretch more depth. Instead, the film rushes through it before the group leaves much of an impact.
Where to Watch The Silence
The Silence has an official Netflix title page. Check that page for availability in your country, as streaming access and maturity labels can vary by region.
▶ View The Silence on NetflixParental Advisory
The film carries a PG-13 rating in the United States for terror, some language, and science-fiction horror violence. It includes creature attacks, deaths, danger involving children, and disturbing cult behavior. The short runtime does not make it a gentle family watch.
Viewers sensitive to animal peril or self-mutilation themes should also be aware of those elements. Netflix may show a different local maturity label depending on the region.
🏆 Tom’s Final Verdict
The Silence is not an outstanding horror film, but it is not completely disposable either. Weak CGI, familiar ideas, and inconsistent creature rules hold it back. Still, Stanley Tucci’s performance and a handful of tense scenes give it enough appeal for a casual watch.
If you are in the mood for a light 90-minute creature feature, you can give this one a chance. Just keep your expectations realistic, and try not to compare every moment with A Quiet Place.
Watch it for the survival setup and Tucci. Do not expect the premise to reach its full potential.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is The Silence based on a book?
Yes. It adapts Tim Lebbon’s 2015 novel of the same name.
Is The Silence a copy of A Quiet Place?
The films share a sound-based survival concept, but Lebbon’s novel predates A Quiet Place. Similarity alone does not establish that the original story copied that film.
Why is Ally deaf?
Ally lost her hearing in an accident at 13. She is 16 during the story, and her family already knows sign language.
What are the creatures called?
They are called Vesps. They are blind, flying, carnivorous creatures that locate prey through sound.
Who stars in The Silence?
The cast includes Stanley Tucci, Kiernan Shipka, Miranda Otto, John Corbett, Kate Trotter, and Kyle Breitkopf.
Is The Silence worth watching?
For a short creature feature, it offers a few tense scenes and a strong Stanley Tucci performance. TomsVerdict gives it 6/10, with reservations about the CGI and underdeveloped story.
Where can I watch The Silence?
Check the film’s official Netflix page for availability in your region.
💬 What Did You Think of The Silence?
Did the Vesps keep you tense, or did the human threat interest you more? Share your verdict in the comments.
For more horror reviews, explore Incantation or The Texas Chain Saw Massacre.
Film information: Netflix Media Center and Rotten Tomatoes. Review and editorial rating: Tom Hence, TomsVerdict.
© TomsVerdict


